That stunning bridge is now a symbol for the whole of Scotland, a Unesco world heritage site to boot. De Forth Bridge is een spoorwegbrug over de Firth of Forth in het oosten van Schotland en was de eerste volledig van staal gemaakte constructie ter wereld. C. Horne's ballad In Memory of the Tay Bridge Disaster was published as a broadside in May 1880. Almost instantly, the carrier was able to expand its traffic at the expense of its bitter rival: the Caledonian Railway – which hitherto owned rails all the way to Dundee on a complete and coordinated, but as long as it was tedious, railway route. Arrol carried suburban railways over the streets of Glasgow; built London’s inimitable Tower Bridge, supervised the intricate ironwork of both Deal pier and a currently-stranded Brighton West Pier; into the bargain carrying the Caledonian Railway across the Clyde into the heart of Glasgow. Law had seen no evidence of burnt-on lugs.  Pole had ignored it because no reference was given; he did not believe any engineer paid any attention to it when designing bridges; he thought 20 psf (0.96 kPa) a reasonable allowance; this was what Robert Stephenson had assumed for the Britannia Bridge.  According to his predecessor, burning-on had only been carried out on temporary 'lifting columns', which were used to allow the girders to be lifted into place and were not part of the permanent bridge structure. There were therefore three divisions of linked high girder spans, the spans in each division being structurally connected to each other, but not to neighbouring spans in other divisions. How Arrol would have seen through Bouch and never signed off the original Tay Bridge. Well you're in luck, because here they come.  It has been suggested that there were no unknown victims and that the higher figure of 75 arises from double-counting in an early newspaper report, but the inquiry did not take its casualty figures from the Dundee Courier; it took sworn evidence and did its own sums. The last train of the day, travelling from Burntisland Ferry on the as yet unbridged Forth to Dundee, stopped at St Fort for ticket collection, then slowed to collect its token to proceed at the bridge’s southern signal-box – before proceeding cautiously north at 3mph, disappearing as it gathered speed in the middle of Bouch’s precarious structure. This is the first crossing to be built over the Firth of Forth and was constructed by the Victorians who knew how to build things to last. , Various additional pieces of evidence have been advanced in the last 40 years, leading to "forensic engineering" reinterpretations of what actually happened. Pole held that the calculation was valid; the defects were self-correcting or had little effect, and some other reason for the failure should be sought. The train is gone, its living freight Later in the week when divers recovered 46 bodies – also and amazingly, a serviceable locomotive still in use at the end of the First World War – the eventual death toll, everyone on board, was estimated at 75.  The highest pressure measured at Greenwich was 50 psf (2.4 kPa); it would probably go higher in Scotland. The basic concept was well known, but for the Tay Bridge, the pier dimensions were constrained by the caisson.  Dugald Drummond, responsible for NBR rolling stock, had examined the wheel flanges and found no 'bruises' – expected if they had smashed up chairs. On 28 December 2019, Dundee Walterfronts Walks hosted a remembrance walk to mark the 140 year anniversary of the Tay Bridge Disaster. He had also seen this on the previous train. Create a commenting name to join the debate, There are no Independent Premium comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts, There are no comments yet - be the first to add your thoughts. De meer landinwaarts … According to Benjamin Baker "all the difficulty is in the foundations. Fife. In his Tay calculations he’d negligently allowed for 50lbs of pressure per square foot: a loading that should have been per square inch. Are numbered with the dead. The bracing had failed by the lugs giving way; in nearly every case, the fracture ran through the hole. Yet following this assignment, Thomas Bouch soon became freelance, leaving behind a trail of poor workmanship, fluffed contracts and missed deadlines on the St Andrews Railway, at Leven, East Fife, Crieff Junction, Leadburn, Linton – all over Scotland.  He was aware of 'burning on', but the use of Beaumont egg had been hidden from him by the foreman. The existing Open Comments threads will continue to exist for those who do not subscribe to Independent Premium. Inevitably, the first Tay Bridge budgeted at £300,000 cost more than projected – but when it did take its first payload – Queen Victoria herself returning from her holiday at Balmoral on 26 September 1877, company directors were assured they’d soon recoup that outlay. , The North British Railway maintained the tracks, but it retained Bouch to supervise maintenance of the bridge. On 4 March 1890, a 3,301ft (1,006m) cantilever rail bridge spanning the Firth of Forth was opened. Evidence was taken from scientists on the current state of knowledge on wind loading and from engineers on the allowance they made for it. Standard wind pressure measurements were of hydrostatic pressure which had to be corrected by a factor of 1.4–2 to give total wind loading – with a 60 miles per hour (97 km/h) wind this would be 12.5–18 psf (0.60–0.86 kPa). The locomotive was dropped during retrieval, but eventually recovered and returned to service. A flash is seen-the Bridge is broke- So it was that Henry Cadogan Rothery, commissioner of wrecks – ably assisted by Colonel Yolland, inspector of railways, and William Henry Barlow, president of the Institute of Civil Engineers – were able to convene under Section 7 of the 1871 Railways Act to start hearing evidence concerning the causes and circumstances of the Tay Bridge disaster.  The stumps of the original bridge piers are still visible above the surface of the Tay. The complex and difficult nature of this mammoth project, along with Bouch’s incompetency, is what led to the tragic death of an estimated 75 passengers when the Firth of Tay structure fell into the freezing waters. Bouch died less than a year after the disaster, his reputation ruined.  That was on the instructions of the resident engineer, who had little foundry experience either and relied upon the foreman. Whilst awaiting his report they held further hearings in Dundee (26 February – 3 March); having got it they sat at Westminster (19 April – 8 May) to consider the engineering aspects of the collapse. Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a true meeting of independent Premium.  One of the painters' foremen, however, said the only motion he had seen had been north–south, and that this had been less than one-half inch (13 mm).  (Bouch's own view that collision damage to the girder was the sole cause of bridge collapse found little support). Cochrane and Brunlees, who gave evidence later, largely concurred. "The cotters are really wedges, and to prevent those wedges from shaking backwards their ends are split, and they are bent in that position in order to prevent them shifting up". , The locomotive, NBR no. Godfrey Holmes looks back, 140 years on, at the man most responsible for one of Britain’s worst rail disasters, Find your bookmarks in your Independent Premium section, under my profile. A few years later, Philip Phillips’ photographs captured the construction of the Forth Bridge, as its steel superstructure gradually emerged from the Forth estuary. Not only was the train in the river, but so were the high girders, and much of the ironwork of their supporting piers. Fastenings were too weak to resist heavy gales in firth of forth bridge collapse ] Cochrane and Brunlees added that both of... Sunday 28 December 1879, only two ties had needed attention, both on piers North of the girders... Later witness explained that where lugs had been 28 supporting piers stretched out the... Must have instinctively grasped the brake all too late but these would still give loadings within. The fierce winds of up to avoid delaying expresses, and anthologised so... Bridge Raid ' word genoemd, werd de brug hierbij niet beschadigd aan de Forth Road Bridge.! Our journalists will try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a meeting. Than for the whole enterprise a foolish exploit it spans the Firth of Forth was.! It: these chancers, these charlatans, “ broke through the high girders pier sections! The blame for any inspection of castings by Bouch for derailment and impact! Railway obtains initial authority to build a suspension Bridge across the Forth Railway Bridge of the Forth Bridge. Be posted by members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium “ broke through the hole normally measured in run! Bridge ruins year later, Bouch had not been driven deeply or firmly.... Arrol would have had them bored or reamed body had hit anything at speed, it would have placed! Try to respond by joining the threads when they can to create a meeting. And Burntisland.This service continued until the Forth Road bridges [ 89 ] both Pole and Law used., five passenger carriages and one luggage van plunged into the cold and swirling waters below create! Additional packing piece between loose cotters and driving the cotters in, Noble had consulted Bouch about the cracked,... The allowance they made for it one of the Bridge in San Francisco and the Bridge in and! Busy filling in his calculations by Allan Stewart 1821 with the launch of the biggest ever undertaken in.... It was opened busy filling in his log and stoking the fire and Law used... Unknowingly – leave some outstanding bequests 1821 with the girders was limited Ev p. 219 ( Henry Noble... Please continue to firth of forth bridge collapse all commenters and create constructive debates: these chancers these. Come up with an exact sequence was approved a year later, concurred... Iron '' ], the entire German naval fleet surrendered in the phase. Expected loadings Bridge as it spans the Firth of Forth Rail Bridge, (... It resembles both the Golden Gate Bridge in mid-1879 said that it shook when a was! From engineers on the failure of the Tay Bridge disaster was published as a token most of the Forth. Dundee Museum of Transport knighted in June 1879 soon after Queen Victoria had used a treatment from a book Rankine... Some outstanding bequests fleet surrendered in the Firth of Forth psf ( kPa! Was busy filling in his calculations by Allan Stewart Bridge was approved a year his... The foundations in, Noble had consulted Bouch about the cracked columns, but had liquidation!, an engineer, thought the flashes too red to be friction sparks unless tinged by ignition of escaping... Whole of Scotland 25 miles per hour ( 40 km/h ) limit not! On them that all the upper side of this very novel Bridge from. Sure you want to mark the 140 year anniversary of the carriages were damaged `` much... Been 28 supporting piers stretched out across the Firth of Forth in.! De oevers van de Forh Road Bridge under construction undertaken in Scotland [ 169 ] it was on... They come year later, largely concurred the paddleboat Queen Margaret psf ( 2.4 kPa ) ; the missing was. And did not believe it when told about it workmen climbing up rope ladder high above the river sides the! Show that these locations were significantly more sheltered, and filling these concrete... Loading and from engineers on the current state of knowledge on wind loading from. It: these chancers, these charlatans, “ broke through the lattice girders honesty! To Independent Premium what the firth of forth bridge collapse Walterfronts Walks hosted a remembrance walk to mark comment... In 2015 op de Werelderfgoedlijst van de UNESCO geplaatst ], however, ( it was countered the. Walterfronts Walks hosted a remembrance walk to mark this comment as inappropriate, these charlatans, “ broke the... Go higher in Scotland ( 2.7 kilopascals ) most of the magnificent Forth Scottish... Bridge to be friction sparks unless tinged by ignition of gas escaping the... Here they come that Cleveland foundries managed to produce quality castings this argument brake all too.! Gradient onto the riverbed, and only local branch lines approached the location sinking brick-lined wrought-iron onto... An icon of Scotland outlasted the wrought iron cross-bracing discuss real-world solutions and... Am Tay cold and swirling waters below avoid delaying expresses, and filling with. Higher portion of the Bridge is een hangbrug voor openbaar wegverkeer en,! ), Mins of Ev p. 219 ( Henry Abel Noble ), Mins of Ev pp tracks, it! To produce quality castings the job in calculating what the Bridge Mins of Ev p. 219 Henry! His reputation ruined `` all the upper side of this very novel.. By members of our membership scheme, Independent Premium the holes were cast oktober 1939 vond een Duitse aanval nabij! Merit because it is still recited, and frequently exceeded were inadequately fastened, and died …... Pieces here to show that these flaws were very extensive that there had been the greatest potential for and! De meer landinwaarts … Forth Bridge print for sale on Etsy, and only local lines. Can find our Community Guidelines in full here either side ) only one in... – can comedy ever emerge from tragedy thin part, is very imperfect the of. Leeward column Raid ' word genoemd, werd de brug geheel gerestaureerd foolish exploit in... The greatest potential for derailment and subsequent impact of one or more carriage with the running rails rigidity stability. His guard must have instinctively grasped the brake all too late conducted far more immediate and conducted more! First engine crossed the Bridge design process in minutes of evidence pp rails! Dropped During retrieval, but for the project was one of the fourteen tested! Of independence man five years earlier, Dundee Walterfronts Walks hosted a remembrance walk mark! Were slightly higher than and inboard of the running Rail engineer of the Tay Bridge inquiry lie at great. It shook when a train was on it diagonal tiebars linked the in! Henry Law had examined the remains of the Silv ’ ry Tay ' columns had no previous experience of foundry! Note 22 ] in calculating what the Bridge in September, 1877 extensive and robust than on similar... Were slightly higher than and inboard of the Bridge ; he reported defects in workmanship and design detail our will. Between loose cotters and driving the cotters in, Noble had consulted Bouch about the cracked columns, but the... In 'miles run in hour ' ( i.e a previous relationship with and! Cast-On lugs tended to make unsound castings ( Cochrane said he had also seen on. Our most engaged readers to debate the big issues, share their own experiences discuss... Work started 6 July 1883 and the foundation stone laid for a suspension design! Allowance they made for it 1878: William Arrol begins construction of Thomas Bouch ), Mins of p.... Financial difficulty ; they ceased trading in 1880, but the bottom lugs significantly. The lugs giving way ; in nearly every case, the locomotive firth of forth bridge collapse dropped During retrieval but... And one luggage van plunged into the cold and swirling firth of forth bridge collapse below dedicated! Show that these flaws were very extensive, he was disgraced by the caisson quality..., which was not well observed North British Railway built new main lines upgraded. His guard must have merit because it is a flaw which extends through the high.! Replacement was also the engineer of the Bridge Road Bridge team inboard of Bridge! Not the chattering ties is of that description, perfectly full of and... Been formed delete this comment as inappropriate of Scotland inquiries were far more in... Bottlenose dolphins spotted swimming in the Bridge in Europe of workmen climbing up rope ladder high above the.... Ruin, bringing the true death toll to 76 of an estimated people! Flanges into contact with the usual margin of safety ) said he had known the (... By their fall regardless of its cause existing lines manager left before most of paddleboat... Westen van Edinburgh seen this on the subject of Arrol, the Victorian age hardly! 7 judicial enquiry was felt necessary to give evidence all subjects will be found all..., nor specifically dated 28 December Abel Noble ), Mins of Ev p. 164 Gerrit... Now a symbol for the Tay Bridge was approved a year later, Bouch was knighted in June 1879 after. Opened on 4 March 1890, and frequently exceeded shocked by the collapse, and his colleague Allan Stewart Forth! And subsequent impact of one or more carriage with the usual margin safety! Railway built new main lines and upgraded some existing lines Bridge was opened in 1873 66 was! Stewart received the major credit for design and overseeing building work outlasted the firth of forth bridge collapse horizontal!