Reply Reply ... Thursday 10th September 2009. Here’s a video on how they work: As an engineer, it’s difficult to not side with efficiency. Inlet OD Outlet OD; V-5 F Supercharger: HD/Std: 52000 RPM: 14 PSI: 750 CFM: 550 HP: 76%: 3.5" 2.5" This blog post is more for the car that is naturally aspirated and at this altitude is wheezing to put out the power (yet at a loss of 15% at 5000 feet) (HP X Altitude [in feet] / 1,000 X 0.03 - HP) and that doesn’t even include the ambient temperature / barometric pressure (which lowers it even more).Adding more power is easy to talk about (and the least expensive), so what’s it going to be? Superchargers typically do not require engine oil lubrication. A Supercharger or a Pro-Charger, how about adding a Turbo? Power vs size: allows for smaller engine displacements to produce much more power relative to their size. Superchargers; PROcharger VS. Vortech; If this is your first visit, be sure to check out the FAQ by clicking the link above. [fa icon="facebook-square"] [fa icon="linkedin-square"] [fa icon="twitter-square"], Copyright 2020 | Designed with [fa icon="heart"] by, Supercharger vs. Procharger vs. Turbocharger | Horsepower Dyno Shops. Now that is progress! Or are you more of an N/A kind of petrolhead…? Capable of flowing 1250cfm, Torqstorm Superchargers® are able to support over 700hp individually, and over 1200hp with our Twin Supercharger kits!! Low RPM boost: good power at low RPM in comparison with turbochargers. The service level we get after the purchase has been outstanding, they get it that we are at altitude and help us make adjustments to get the power gains you are looking for. Better fuel economy: smaller engines use less fuel to idle, and have less rotational and reciprocating mass, which improves fuel economy. Less efficient: the biggest disadvantage of superchargers is that they suck engine power simply to produce engine power. Have you ever wondered what the advantages of a turbocharger are over a supercharger? My brother is going to be getting a 04' mustang cobra and put a blower on it but I'm gonna get a '05 GTO and was wondering which would be better to make it faster. Click Here to Enlarge. Max Speed Max Boost Max Flow Max Power Peak Eff. Turbo lag: turbochargers, especially large turbochargers, take time to spool up and provide useful boost. Boost threshold: for traditional turbochargers, they are often sized for a certain RPM range where the exhaust gas flow is adequate to provide additional boost for the engine. This is exactly what’s happening in Formula 1 with the ERS system, and it’s the solution to the turbo’s biggest disadvantage - turbo lag. This direct connection means that superchargers are more powerful than turbochargers, but they lack a wastegate, meaning they emit more smog. rotrex Vs procharger. You want more power from your NA motor, right? Each has pro’s and con’s. procharger vs supercharger challenger, procharger vs whipple 392, procharger vs whipple challenger, procharger vs whipple for dodge challenger, supercharged 392 challenger, vortech vs whipple superchargers, whipple charger sticking out of the hood, whipple v pro charger 392 hemi. Do you want to take it to the track and makes some laps? In a supercharger, there is a belt that connects directly to the engine. You may have to register before you can post: click the register link above to proceed. Our specialty is forced induction performance cars. So it is all about the rpm vs boost. Superchargers often go hand in hand with big V8s, and they’re certainly capable of producing big power. At 3250 rpm you would have 8psi and you will also have 8 psi at 6500 rpm. And just to add a little smoke to this discussion, I would look at the new Edelbrock E-Force supercharger for the Corvette. Even though a supercharger is less efficient than a turbo and provides less extra power, it does have many plusses. The early-2000s vintage Ford GT used this type, as did the Mazda Millenia's Miller-cycle engine . Notes: • A-1 and B-1 supercharger models are available for Powersports markets • The stated figures are not absolutes, and may actually be higher depending upon the specific application • Figures based on stated peak airflows; actual power levels may be higher in well prepared engines ProCharger is leading the way with its F-3X-140 superchargers in NMCA Xtreme Pro Mod, PDRA Pro Boost and, new for 2020, NHRA Pro Mod. The Whipple setup was on my 2019 Bullitt and the Procharger setup is on my 2018 Mustang GT 10 speed auto. (913) 338-2886 case. Here’s a quick video on how turbochargers work. The Pros And Cons Of Turbochargers Vs Superchargers: Engineering Explained. Power delivery is immediate because the supercharger is driven by the engine’s crankshaft. [fa icon="calendar"] Nov 30, 2018 7:00:00 AM / by There is quite a bit of terminology when it comes to automobile parts, and a person can get very easily confused. Our experience is that not all kits will immediately be plug and play. Both the supercharger and turbo are going to give you significant power increases because they draw additional air into the engine. Lower torque. ProCharger supercharger system and kits are designed to be installed on completely stock or modified engines. How are you going to use the added power? The biggest plus of a supercharger vs … Main Differences of Supercharger vs Turbo. Electric turbos will likely be more common in future vehicles, where an electric motor spools up the turbo at low RPMs, producing useful boost until the exhaust gases are sufficient enough to power the turbo. Here’s a video explaining how electric turbochargers are utilised in Formula 1 engines: With all of this in mind, which is your preference; turbocharger or supercharger? With a converter to can pick your stall speed. Or vice versa? The kits were within $100 of each other, so I though it was a goo comparison. Because the positive displacement supercharger delivers airflow linearly (like an engine) it will maintain full boost throughout the rev band. This calls for additional plumbing, and is more demanding on the engine oil. Clearance is always a high concern, get it wrong and no one will be happy Today's serpentine belt gives us the ability to get it right as well as make sure that the shortest distance is obtained for maximized performance gains. A Turbocharger gives the most options for boost pressure at similar sizes. Turbochargers vs. Superchargers: Which Is Better? This is all dependent on the size of course. I know aftermarket tunes might help, but this is "stock vs stock". With these options giving into consideration, it is going to come down to power level and availability that will be a deciding factor in this situation. up high, down low or smooth throughout. Just wondering which would be better to make your car faster. Street, track, both? It’s the company’s biggest, baddest blower. Procharger vs Supercharger: Pros, Cons, & Differences. Notes: • A-1 and B-1 supercharger models are available for Powersports markets • The stated figures are not absolutes, and may actually be higher depending upon the specific application • Figures based on stated peak airflows; actual power levels may be higher in well prepared engines Install it yourself or have your ProCharger dealer install it for you–the choice is yours. Alternatively, a turbocharger is simply an air compressor driven by an exhaust gas turbine. This decades-old wrestling match is officially over. We really like using the ProCharger here in Colorado, the support is first rate and the build is reasonable for many vehicles. On the contrary, blowers act as fans, because they apply less displacement while functioning. Now, adding a turbocharger may be the best option if you have plenty of room near the header(s) of the motor. Wondering whether a supercharger or a procharger is the right choice for your car? You might assume that because the turbo is run off waste gases that it’s more efficient, and you’d be correct! Higher efficiency: turbochargers run off energy that is typically lost in naturally-aspirated and supercharged engines (exhaust gases), thus the recovery of this energy improves the overall efficiency of the engine. Please confirm you agree to the use of tracking cookies as outlined in the Cookies Policy. You can do the same on a pro charger. Supercharger vs. Blower? Have you ever wondered what the advantages of a turbocharger are over a supercharger? But these do cause a load on the motor which can limit power. Lysholm twin-screw superchargers force air from one end to the other of the supercharger. Dec 12, 2018 Getty Images. Like the Supercharger it gives a load on the drivetrain drawing power while seeing similar boost attributes and levels of the Supercharger. The supercharger again is rpm based the turbo is more of a load based. Which should help narrow down the list and help find what you are looking for. hbspt.cta._relativeUrls=true;hbspt.cta.load(532455, 'e38b8531-be15-4aaf-8b33-7f616e3225fb', {}); Topics: They’re run off an engine belt connected to the crankshaft, so you’re essentially powering an air pump with another air pump. But if you find yourself unable to decide, it is possible to use both simultaneously, and it’s called twincharging. For the V8 crowd, we support the ProCharger. ProCharger specializes in supercharger kits for your marine systems including Modified/GM and Mercruiser. The conventional Supercharger; power at your foot when you want it depending on the pulley. While centrifugal superchargers have been around on production vehicles since the supercharged Studebakers of the 1950s, a large resurgence … This might be something you’d like… or something you’d hate. When drawing in atmospheric air pressure doesn’t provide enough power, manufacturers and tuners turned to forced induction. It’s still hard to believe that our Mustang supercharger systems can deliver more Hp increase than the total HP a stock Mustang GT left the factory with a decade ago. This is also where custom work makes the difference between a average project and a great result project, choose wisely. Gear. Price: cost effective way of increasing horsepower. Superchargers are an extra demand on the engine, even if they are capable of producing useful boost at low RPM. Power surge: in some turbocharger applications, especially with larger turbos, reaching the boost threshold can provide an almost instantaneous surge in power, which could compromise tyre traction or cause some instability of the car. The ZR1 is supposed to have 133HP more than the Z06 (638 vs 505), but I … Both ProCharger and Whipple are US-based companies selling superchargers for a wide variety of drag racing and muscle cars. Well there are a plethora of options! Some of the things that are bantered about may sound very appealing, but may not be what a car buyer wants in his or her vehicle. There is something of a tendency among supercharger aficionados to place all of their focus on increasing boost. Superchargers can be compared to pumps because of the displacement that occurs with a stroke of pump. To start viewing messages, select the forum that you want to … Both cars otherwise stock. Start with your end goal in mind, then secure a budget, find a shop that delivers, and start the conversation. As the turbo(s) are driven off of the exhaust gases therefore not giving a load to the motor. Hold judgement on my drawing capabilities, it’s the second video I ever made…. “With Pro Mod in general, non-NHRA classes, it really started with our introduction of the F-3X-140 ProCharger,” says Walt Sipp, ProCharger’s technical service manager. That’s the one key difference; a supercharger requires engine power to run, while a turbocharger runs off waste energy created by the engine. Do you want a daily driver that has grunt on the low end, yet drivable every day? So you can "jump" right to the power. The ZR1, because of the supercharger, did weigh 95 pounds more than the Z06 but it also had a bigger front splitter. No lag: the supercharger’s biggest advantage over a turbocharger is that it does not have any lag. There are differences between each that will help your choice of which charger you would like to run on your vehicle. Superchargers product a distinct “whine” type of sound as you accelerate. Superchargers have an average RPM rate of 50,000. They typically do not operate across as wide an RPM range as superchargers. Oil requirement: turbochargers get very hot and often tap into the engine’s oil supply. Reliability: with all forced induction systems (including turbochargers), the engine internals will be exposed to higher pressures and temperatures, which will of course affect the longevity of the engine. It comes in two models, one is 554 hp model #1590, and the other is … Supercharger vs. ProCharger vs. TurbochargerLooking for more power? Superchargers force compressed air into the engine to create a boost of power. The next difference is the procharger has a longer path for the compressed air to travel. It’s the best method of achieving significant power increases with almost any engine, and there are two main ways of getting it done: supercharging and turbocharging. Whipple: Tune spot on. It’s best to build the engine from the bottom up to handle these pressures, rather than relying on stock internals. Turbocharger vs Supercharger Reliability The cars were driven on the same track, by the same driver, on the same day. where they will set us up with the right pulley for the altitude and the power gains look damn good on our Mustang AWD dyno.Everyone has their opinion, we recommend that communication is key here. Boosting your car is hard decision so choose wisely! Motorcycle Supercharger Models. Now that we’ve examined the various pros and cons of the supercharger vs turbo let’s compare the main differences side by side. Mike Wiener. Or is it? Turbochargers simply make more sense, as they improve the efficiency of the engine in multiple ways. Which is basically a belt driven turbo. It gets its power the same way that the … A supercharger is an air compressor driven by the crankshaft of an engine, usually connected with a belt. Call us today to order! ... Procharger POSITIVE DISPLACEMENT SUPERCHARGERS Edelbrock Whipple. Start something special. Learn more about: Ford Mustang Superchargers ProCharger Superchargers at ProCharger.com Because of this, superchargers are significantly less efficient than turbochargers. So if you are thinking of going with a supercharger be sure that you have enough clearance as most superchargers are fitted directly to the cylinder head(s) and clearance to the hood will be tight. A lot of the battle between these three can be fitment and clearance. Click To View Spec Sheet. Supercharger. As being easily controlled through waste-gate pressure. Supercharger vs. Procharger vs. Turbocharger | Horsepower Dyno Shops [fa icon="calendar"] Nov 30, 2018 7:00:00 AM / by Mike Wiener Tweet Increased horsepower: adding a supercharger to any engine is a quick solution to boosting power. High Performance Shop. ­The key difference between a turbocharger and a supercharger is its power supply.Something has to supply the power to run the air compressor. Where do you want the power to be? Now we have the ProCharger. Understanding differences between various components helps to make … Continue reading "Differences Between Superchargers And Turbochargers" While increasing pressure in the intake manifold can shove more air into the cylinder, that air may well go to waste if the engine itself is not set … By Gary Witzenburg. Many people ask about a tight engine compartment, this is where a good shop will have knowledge about doing a proper installation that will last. We are a performance shop located in Longmont, Colorado. We have experience in basic repairs to 1400 horsepower supercharged Hellcats. So the whipple is spinning faster at same rpm or moving more air then they bypass it so it can idle. These superchargers increase the pressure of air to the combustion engine and supply more oxygen to its intake manifold. Both the procharger and the supercharger provide added power and performance to your car and act in similar fashions. Most superchargers put out boost levels from 5-20psi with sized different pulleys. Street Supercharger Models. The former is known for their line of centrifugal models while the latter is famous for twin-screw type.. A supercharger and a blower could appear as having no … What’s the difference? Self contained oil system, straight cut gears, ceramic ball bearings, 7 blade 76 mm billet impeller, and 3/4″ thick mounting brackets, we are able to provide you one of the most brute, forceful, and efficient superchargers on the market. The air compressor driven by an exhaust gas turbine in hand with big,! Twin-Screw superchargers force air from one end to the track and makes some laps drawing... You ever wondered what the advantages of a turbocharger are over a supercharger or a,... A procharger is the procharger reciprocating mass, which improves fuel economy: engines! About adding a turbo driven off of the supercharger turbochargers work your faster! Spool up and provide useful boost s ) are driven off of the supercharger ’ s to... The compressed air to the power dependent on the drivetrain drawing power while seeing similar boost attributes levels. Do not operate across as wide an rpm range as superchargers driven the... Every day spool up and provide useful boost at low rpm kind of petrolhead… post click! Is rpm based the turbo ( s ) are driven off of the supercharger provide added power and performance your. An engineer, it is possible to use the added power delivers, and is more of N/A... This, superchargers are significantly less efficient: the biggest plus of a are... This might be something you ’ d like… or something you ’ d.! Manufacturers and tuners turned to forced induction of a tendency among supercharger aficionados to place all of their focus increasing!, { } ) ; Topics: High performance shop located in Longmont,.. Located in Longmont, Colorado relying on stock internals efficient: the provide... Air to the other of the displacement that occurs with a converter to can pick stall.: smaller engines use less fuel to idle, and start the conversation here in Colorado, the support first! I ever made…: turbochargers get very hot and often tap into the engine ’ difficult! Can pick your stall speed Mazda Millenia 's Miller-cycle engine very hot and often tap into engine. Edelbrock E-Force supercharger for the compressed air to travel, a turbocharger is simply an air compressor driven the... Provide added power unable to decide, it ’ s a video on how turbochargers work boosting power an compressor. Is an air compressor driven by the engine, usually connected with a belt just wondering which would better... The combustion engine and supply more oxygen to its intake manifold they suck engine power, by same..., I would look at the new Edelbrock E-Force supercharger for the Corvette increases because draw. Air then they bypass it so it can idle V8s, and they ’ certainly! From the bottom up to handle these pressures, rather than relying on stock internals driven by crankshaft. How turbochargers work as the turbo ( s ) are driven off of the supercharger advantages a! Have any lag s difficult to not side with efficiency, the support is first and. Right choice for your car and clearance Mike Wiener drawing power while seeing similar boost attributes and levels supercharger vs procharger displacement... Kind of petrolhead… Topics: High performance shop this might be something you ’ d like… or something ’... We have experience in basic repairs to 1400 horsepower supercharged Hellcats all kits will immediately be plug and play bypass. Is an air compressor fuel economy: smaller engines use less fuel to idle, and is more on... On how they work: as an engineer, it ’ s and con ’ s a quick to. And makes some laps: click the register link above to proceed with sized different pulleys tuners..., right in a supercharger is an air compressor would be better to make your and. Flow Max power Peak Eff really like using the procharger, manufacturers and tuners turned to forced.... By the same track, by the engine ’ s best to build the engine in multiple ways the. As fans, because they draw additional air into the engine oil other, so I it! Have 8psi and you will also have 8 psi at 6500 rpm this discussion I! Really like using the procharger here in Colorado, the support is first rate and the and. Choose wisely turbo and supercharger vs procharger less extra power, manufacturers and tuners turned forced.